Click to call us at (954) 568-3636


8 SE 8th Street, Fort Lauderdale FL 33316

Click to call us at (954) 568-3636

Settling a Personal Injury Claim Vs. Going to Trial in Florida

When people think of lawsuits, most will immediately think of a fierce jury trial where lawyers for both sides fight for their clients to the bitter end. Indeed, some lawsuits do go that route. However, the vast majority of lawsuits never make it to trial. This is because, in many circumstances, both sides come to an agreement beforehand and mutually decide to drop the matter. This is called a “settlement.” In a settlement, both sides of a lawsuit agree to terms, and the matter does not make it to court.

There is no set timeframe for how long a settlement takes. A defendant may choose to settle right away, or they may do so right before trial, or not at all. Sometimes, settling a case is the most beneficial option for both parties. However, since each case is unique, there is no guaranteed way to determine whether a settlement is the best route.

If you are considering settling or filing a lawsuit, call The Law Offices of David I. Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A.’s Ft. Lauderdale personal injury lawyers for a free case review at (954) 751-4258.

What is a Settlement?

In law, a settlement is an agreement between both sides of a case to resolve the dispute outside of a jury trial. This is an alternative way to settle a dispute that does not end in a verdict claiming one side is liable or not.

Settlements sometimes have a stigma surrounding them. Plaintiffs may feel like they are being cheated of their day in court or that they are cow-toeing to the defendant. However, this is not the case. Sometimes, a settlement is the best option to make sure that the plaintiff gets their needs met.

Our Miami personal injury lawyer’s job is to get you a “win” in your lawsuit. A win does not necessarily need to be in the courtroom. If you can accomplish what you need without a jury trial, you may want to consider that option.

Why Settle a Personal Injury Lawsuit in Florida?

Many plaintiffs may question whether it truly is a good idea to settle a case and not go all the way to a jury trial. For some, settling may feel like giving up or throwing in the towel. Alternatively, some plaintiffs might think that accepting a settlement offer from the other side makes them look weak, or they could have done better if they went all the way to trial. The reality of deciding whether or not to settle a case is quite complicated, and no two cases will have the same set of factors to consider when choosing to accept a settlement or not.

It is important to note that settling is an option you have – and nothing more. There are situations where our Palm Beach County personal injury lawyers may advise that settling may be a good move, but the ultimate decision will always be up to you.

A Good Offer

If a defendant makes a settlement offer that satisfies what you wanted out of the lawsuit anyway, you should seriously consider accepting the offer. For example, if you need $500,000 damages and the defendant offers a $600,000 settlement, it would be wise to seriously consider accepting that offer.

Some plaintiffs may feel like a defendant offering to settle is an admission of liability or an indication that their defense is weak. That is not necessarily true. Many defendants will offer to settle out of genuine sympathy for the plaintiff. Do not lose sight of the goal – getting the compensation you need – by trying to “pull one over” on the defendant.

Cost Savings

Lawsuits are expensive. This is especially true of a case drags on for months or even years. Legal fees can quickly add up if a case spirals out of control or a trial goes on for a very long time. Settling a case early is an effective way to both resolve a dispute and save on legal fees.

Guaranteed Outcome

A settlement is a guaranteed outcome because both parties come to an agreement. The reality of any lawsuit that goes to trial is that it is a toss-up. No matter how air-tight each side believes their case to be, the ultimate decision on whether the defendant will be liable or not lies with the jury.

If the prospect of an unknown trial outcome is distressing, settlement may be a good alternative.

How Long Does it Take to Settle a Personal Injury Lawsuit in Florida?

There is no set length of time for how short or long it will be before you can settle a case. This is because either party can offer to settle a case at any time before trial. This could be right after the plaintiff files a lawsuit, the day before trial, or at any point in between. Sometimes, a party will reject a settlement offer, the receive another offer an accept the second offer.

Generally, settlements happen as more facts reveal themselves through discovery – the process by which sides of a case share information and establish a universal base of facts. For example, the defendant may feel they have a strong case when some new information that is bad for their argument comes to light. They may choose to settle to try and avoid damage to their reputation in court.

In rare instances, a settlement offer will happen right away. This generally happens when one side does not wish to take a case to court. In some instances, you can use this to your advantage to negotiate a better settlement. However, be careful to not overstep, or the other side could withdraw their settlement offer entirely.

Talk to Our Florida Personal Injury Lawyers Today

Our Orlando personal injury lawyers with Law Offices of David I. Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A. can be reached at (954) 751-4258 to discuss your case.

David I. Fuchs is a personal injury attorney in Fort Lauderdale and the founder of David I. Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A. David has an extensive background representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases and has been practicing law for over three decades.

David I Fuchs

Attorney at Law, David I Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A.

Injured In An Accident?

Get in touch for a Free Case Review

Client Testimonials

Saarina Polanco
Saarina Polanco
Yo recomiendo éste avoga son muy bueno cien por ciento 👍👍👍💯💯💯
Fabio Varens
Fabio Varens
David I. Fuchs comes highly recommended for anyone in need of a top-notch accident attorney in Fort Lauderdale. With over three decades of experience, his firm is known for its client-focused approach, maintaining strong communication and offering personalized legal strategies. They are particularly adept at negotiating with large insurance companies and handling complex courtroom cases. A great choice for effective and compassionate legal representation.
Ethan Cohen
Ethan Cohen
Great accident lawyer. Gave us invaluable advice when an air conditioning truck hit my car
Israel Andrade
Israel Andrade
I cannot speak highly enough of Dr. David I. Fuchs, the injury law expert in Fort Lauderdale. When I urgently needed legal guidance, he was on the spot, providing precise and honest information. David's quick responsiveness, combined with his accuracy and transparency, made a significant impact during a challenging time I was facing due to a total loss in a car accident. I greatly appreciate his professionalism and recommend his services to anyone seeking a trustworthy and reliable injury law attorney in South Florida.
Darcy Israel
Darcy Israel
They did a great job with keeping me updated with my case. I would refer them to anybody in the future.
Matthew S.
Matthew S.
I just want to say thank you to Mr. Fuchs he personally took a call on Saturday and due to the nature of circumstances he was not able to take the case but he provided me with the proper means to go about the case and offered any advice that he can give along the way for my situation. Thank you for listening and your support.
tom neenan
tom neenan
Mr. Fuchs handled my case fast and always got back to me to explain all details. I recommend his friendly demeanor and kindness. I felt like family. Thank you very much for the service and wonderful settlement.
Wendy Janet Mendez
Wendy Janet Mendez
I recommend The Law Offices of David Fuchs. They are very professional and care about their clients. I got into a car accident and the whole process was really smooth.
Lynne N.
Lynne N.
David Fuchs and his staff were consummate professionals when I needed a law office to represent my injury case. They communicated the process in detail and kept me apprised of the progress as necessary. It was a relief to be able to rely on them during a stressful time. It was nice to have the personalized attention of a smaller law firm as my champion.
When you’re involved in an accident and have injuries you need an attorney who is experienced AND who will give you the personal attention you need. You want someone who the insurance companies know won’t just accept any offer to make a commission. That's what separates Mr. Fuchs from the rest, especially the large law firms. He knows the law and he will fight for you like you are a member of his family. I highly recommend him to anyone who has been in an accident and needs aggressive representation for their injuries and other financial losses that happen as a result!

We’ve Recovered Hundreds of Millions of Dollars for Clients.


Premises Liability


Negligent Supervision


Hotel Slip & Fall


Car Accident in Broward County

$1.8 Million

Traumatic Brain Injury


Multi-Vehicle Accident


Motorcycle Accident


Wrongful Death

Blog Archive