Click to call us at (954) 568-3636


8 SE 8th Street, Fort Lauderdale FL 33316

Click to call us at (954) 568-3636

How Do Insurance Companies Calculate Personal Injury Claims in Florida?

After an accident, dealing with insurance companies can add stress to an already challenging situation. Juggling medical care, transportation, and car repairs is overwhelming enough without someone else determining the value of your experience.

Insurance companies use precise formulas to calculate settlement offers based on factors like the number of people involved, repair estimates for damaged vehicles, and medical reports. However, they might not offer the full amount compared to what a court might award because they want you to accept less. We can help you understand how they arrive at their compensation packages and what to keep in mind when negotiating. Remember that you can always speak to a lawyer for assistance with negotiations.

For a free case evaluation with our Ft. Lauderdale personal injury attorneys, contact the Law Offices of David I. Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A. at (954) 751-4258 today.

How Does an Insurance Company Calculate Personal Injury Claims in Florida?

When an insurance company calculates compensation after an accident, it will typically add up injury and vehicle damage costs. However, each case is different, so calculations will vary depending on the severity of the accident. Fortunately, our Miami personal injury attorneys have the knowledge and experience to calculate the value of your claim and can help you recover a settlement that reflects your damages. The following factors are the main considerations made when insurance companies calculate personal injury claims in Florida:

Damage to the Vehicles Involved

When determining the appropriate amount of compensation for a damaged vehicle, several factors must be considered by insurance representatives. These include the original sale value of the car and how much it has depreciated, as well as the condition of the vehicle and its mileage at the time of the accident.

The cost of repairs for different types of damage can vary significantly. More common types of damage might require lower costs for repairs because replacement parts are easier to find. For example, if the damage is simply to a fender, it might be possible to buff it out or replace it with a new one at a relatively low cost. However, if the damage is more severe and affects critical parts of the vehicle, such as the engine or chassis, the cost of repairs could be much higher.

If the cost of repairing the damage is more than the value of the vehicle after depreciation, the insurance company will typically declare the vehicle a total loss and offer to pay its remaining value rather than repair it.

Determining the replacement parts for imported vehicles or those with aftermarket modifications can be challenging and might lead to less favorable outcomes. This is because the insurance company will typically use the market value of needed replacement parts. If the vehicle is rare or an import, finding these parts for sale can be difficult and expensive. Insurance settlements might also only provide compensation for cheaper generic parts rather than the right manufacturer’s official parts, disregarding any additional time and effort spent on aftermarket modifications.

Injuries to the Parties Involved

To determine the compensatory value for injuries resulting from a car accident, insurance companies might consider factors similar to those used for vehicle damages. These factors might include information about the injured person that could either mitigate or exacerbate the injury. For instance, age, activity level, earning potential if affected by the injury, and vulnerability could all play a role in the settlement offer.

For example, consider two people involved in a car accident caused by another driver’s negligence: an elderly retired driver and a highly accomplished track and field athlete. If the elderly driver sustained a broken collarbone, they would be compensated for medical expenses, but not for lost wages or earning potential, as they are no longer working. Conversely, if the athlete suffered the same injury, it could impact their ability to receive scholarships, sponsorships, or opportunities to compete, resulting in a much larger compensation package. Despite having the same injury, their unique circumstances would affect the value of their compensation.

How Does an Insurance Company Determine a Settlement Amount for a Florida Personal Injury Claim?

In Florida, insurance companies use different methods to determine compensation amounts for car accidents depending on the claim being made. If the claimant is seeking payment for medical costs, the insurance company will add up the expenses. However, if the claimant is also claiming damages for pain and suffering, the calculation becomes more complex.

The term “pain and suffering” is a legal term used to describe the emotional and mental impact of an injury caused by a car accident. Many individuals who experience a serious car accident deal with lasting chronic pain and psychological distress. As a settlement is essentially an agreement between the insurance company and the claimant, the insurance company will typically try to include these damages in their compensation package to make it more appealing and reasonable for the claimant.

Insurance companies typically use a method called the “multiplier method” to determine pain and suffering damages. This method is based on the idea that accidents with higher direct costs, such as medical bills and property damage, are likely to have caused more pain and suffering. The formula used for this method will vary based on the nature of the injuries sustained. For example, a high-speed collision might warrant a higher multiplier than a minor fender bender.

If you find yourself dealing with another driver’s insurance agent after a car accident, it’s usually because the other driver was at fault. However, it’s important to keep in mind that the insurance agent’s main goal is to limit their company’s liability. They might try to convince you to agree to a settlement that is much lower than what you could potentially recover in court.

Remember, insurance agents are not on your side. That being said, our team can help you communicate with the insurance company, negotiate a fair settlement, and even take your case to court if necessary to ensure you receive proper compensation for the damages you sustained in the accident.

How Long Do I Have to File a Lawsuit If I Can Not Reach a Settlement with an Insurance Company in Florida?

A new law was signed by the governor of Florida in 2023 that has impacted the process of personal injury cases. The “statute of limitations” has been altered, which determines the time limit for filing a lawsuit. Previously, personal injury victims had four years to file a lawsuit, but now in Florida, the time limit has been reduced to two years.

As a result, taking prompt action is crucial. Delaying could result in negative consequences, as there is a limited amount of time to gather evidence and locate witnesses before potentially filing a lawsuit. If you have suffered from an injury, it is possible that you might not have to file a lawsuit. However, if you do, it is important to keep in mind that you only have two years to do so. After this time has passed, the defense can ask the court to dismiss your case, which it will.

Our Florida Personal Injury Lawyers Can Help

Contact the Law Offices of David I. Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A. today at (954) 751-4258 for a free case assessment with our Florida personal injury lawyers.

David I. Fuchs is a personal injury attorney in Fort Lauderdale and the founder of David I. Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A. David has an extensive background representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases and has been practicing law for over three decades.

David I Fuchs

Attorney at Law, David I Fuchs, Injury & Accident Lawyer, P.A.

Injured In An Accident?

Get in touch for a Free Case Review

Client Testimonials

Saarina Polanco
Saarina Polanco
Yo recomiendo éste avoga son muy bueno cien por ciento 👍👍👍💯💯💯
Fabio Varens
Fabio Varens
David I. Fuchs comes highly recommended for anyone in need of a top-notch accident attorney in Fort Lauderdale. With over three decades of experience, his firm is known for its client-focused approach, maintaining strong communication and offering personalized legal strategies. They are particularly adept at negotiating with large insurance companies and handling complex courtroom cases. A great choice for effective and compassionate legal representation.
Ethan Cohen
Ethan Cohen
Great accident lawyer. Gave us invaluable advice when an air conditioning truck hit my car
Israel Andrade
Israel Andrade
I cannot speak highly enough of Dr. David I. Fuchs, the injury law expert in Fort Lauderdale. When I urgently needed legal guidance, he was on the spot, providing precise and honest information. David's quick responsiveness, combined with his accuracy and transparency, made a significant impact during a challenging time I was facing due to a total loss in a car accident. I greatly appreciate his professionalism and recommend his services to anyone seeking a trustworthy and reliable injury law attorney in South Florida.
Darcy Israel
Darcy Israel
They did a great job with keeping me updated with my case. I would refer them to anybody in the future.
Matthew S.
Matthew S.
I just want to say thank you to Mr. Fuchs he personally took a call on Saturday and due to the nature of circumstances he was not able to take the case but he provided me with the proper means to go about the case and offered any advice that he can give along the way for my situation. Thank you for listening and your support.
tom neenan
tom neenan
Mr. Fuchs handled my case fast and always got back to me to explain all details. I recommend his friendly demeanor and kindness. I felt like family. Thank you very much for the service and wonderful settlement.
Wendy Janet Mendez
Wendy Janet Mendez
I recommend The Law Offices of David Fuchs. They are very professional and care about their clients. I got into a car accident and the whole process was really smooth.
Lynne N.
Lynne N.
David Fuchs and his staff were consummate professionals when I needed a law office to represent my injury case. They communicated the process in detail and kept me apprised of the progress as necessary. It was a relief to be able to rely on them during a stressful time. It was nice to have the personalized attention of a smaller law firm as my champion.
When you’re involved in an accident and have injuries you need an attorney who is experienced AND who will give you the personal attention you need. You want someone who the insurance companies know won’t just accept any offer to make a commission. That's what separates Mr. Fuchs from the rest, especially the large law firms. He knows the law and he will fight for you like you are a member of his family. I highly recommend him to anyone who has been in an accident and needs aggressive representation for their injuries and other financial losses that happen as a result!

We’ve Recovered Hundreds of Millions of Dollars for Clients.


Premises Liability


Negligent Supervision


Hotel Slip & Fall


Car Accident in Broward County

$1.8 Million

Traumatic Brain Injury


Multi-Vehicle Accident


Motorcycle Accident


Wrongful Death

Blog Archive